14k Gold, 18k Gold, Or Platinum Engagement Ring Setting, Which One is Best?

by Edward Calderazzo
(Aventura, Florida)

We'll start with 14k and 18k gold. Both of these metals are perfect for engagement rings. Both of these gold alloys are much less expensive than platinum. 14k gold, whether it be yellow or white, has a 58.33% gold content and the rest of the alloy is other harder metals such as nickel, copper, palladium or zinc. On the other hand, 18k gold, whether it be white or yellow has a gold content of 75% with the rest of the metal or alloy mixture being other hard metals. So, 14k gold, whether it be white or yellow, is harder than 18k gold, therefore, being a more secure choice for diamond engagement rings. Platinum on the other hand is very rare and it's the hardest(60% more dense than gold) jewelry metal.

Platinum is much stronger, heavier and more expensive than gold. Platinum won't tarnish, however it will scratch overtime just like gold so it may need to be re-polished. Platinum is not only expensive due to its rarity, hardness and shine, it's also expensive because it takes an extremely skilled craftsman to work it. Platinum is the best choice of metal if the engagement ring setting is holding a big center diamond, however you can have a 14k gold ring setting made with a platinum head to hold the center diamond.

All three of these metals have been used for decades as ring settings. As a jeweler I've had the pleasure of overseeing a jewelry repair department so over the years I've seen a few rings returned for repair. If it was a ring they were returing, it was usually an 18k gold ring with a little accent diamond or diamonds that had fallen out. My educated guess is the 18k gold alloy was not hard enough. And let me tell you, women don't like to part with their engagement rings for a repair.

Both 14k and 18k white gold diamond rings will need to be rhodium plated over time and this depends on how much the ring is worn by the lucky lady. Rhodium plating keeps the metal looking white, this is not expensive at all. Don't fret, sometimes for a gold ring to tarnish, it will take years of wear. I'm talking about high quality gold alloys. All in all, it's up to you, the shopper, these three metals have been used for decades and in some cases centuries for engagement ring settings. For those savvy shoppers, here's a tip - a 14k white gold engagement ring setting with a platinum head could be the best choice.

Comments for 14k Gold, 18k Gold, Or Platinum Engagement Ring Setting, Which One is Best?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Jun 12, 2009
something interesting
by: Steve

you mentioned that platinum will scratch over time just like gold, but when my wife and i were shopping for our rings we heard that there's a difference...

of course all metals scratch, but what I think is noteworthy about platinum is that when it scratches, some of the metal is simply displaced. with gold you're actually loosing slivers of the metal and therefore losing volume and value over time.

hope it's true because we decided to go with platinum!

May 15, 2009
Great Work!
by: Tom Brownstein

Hi my name is Tom and I just wanted to congratulate you on a terrific and useful site. I just started a blog of my own at http://tungstenringsguide.com where I talk about tungsten rings. I thought it might be to our mutual advantage to exchange links. If you're interested, please drop me a line at info@tungstenringsguide.com. Keep up the great work!

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Totally Free Engagement Ring Advice.